What is code review?

Definition

Code review compares a proposed change with the project's requirements and surrounding implementation. Reviewers may inspect logic, failure handling, security implications and maintainability. Human judgment and automated analysis can contribute different kinds of evidence.

Review does not prove that every defect has been found. It works alongside relevant tests and other checks, and should focus on issues that affect the intended behaviour. Approval authority and unresolved findings need clear handling when review is automated.

ELI5

Code review is checking what a software change actually does before accepting it. The reviewer compares the change with the requested result and looks for problems.

For example, a filtering change might accidentally show completed items when the user selected unfinished items. A reviewer can spot the reversed condition, and a behavior test can confirm that the corrected filter works.

Is code review the same as running tests?

No. Review examines the change and its reasoning, while tests exercise selected behaviour. The two can complement each other.

Can automated review guarantee safe code?

No. Automated findings and approvals still need appropriate scope, evidence and authority.

  1. Theo Browne beside the words Agent Loops on black.
    Theo Browne Explores Coding Agent Loops
    Theo24m 45s1 VIEW
  2. Andrew Norrish in a blue shirt beside the headline AI Code Review on black.
  3. Nick Nisi beside the words Fly Code Review.
  4. Killian Carlsen-Phelan and Taylor Luttrell-Williams discussing AI code review.
  5. Theo Browne beside the words AI Entered the Kernel
  6. Theo Browne on a black background beside the blue-and-white headline DISPOSABLE AI CODE.
  7. A task-list search and filter interface on black beside the headline DESKTOP AGENT TEST.
  8. Flat connected code icons surround the words CODING AGENT TEAMS.
  9. Portrait of Alex Finn beside the words Build a Loop Not a Prompt
  10. Pierce Freeman and Richard Diehl Martinez in blue and white tops against black, alongside the blue and white headline "VIBE CODING MEETS REAL DATA".
Definition card for code review: What is code review?

Code review examines proposed source changes to assess their correctness, clarity and suitability before or around integration.