What is counterexample?

Definition

A counterexample must satisfy the conditions of the claim and fail its conclusion. It can be enough to settle whether the general claim holds.

Finding an example can take substantial work. Reviewing it means checking both the conditions and the failure it demonstrates.

ELI5

A counterexample is one case that shows an 'every case' claim is wrong.

For example, the claim that every marble in a bag is red is contradicted by finding a blue marble in that same bag, provided the claim really applies to all of its marbles.

How many are needed to disprove a universal claim?

One well-verified counterexample can refute a claim that a conclusion holds for every qualifying case.

What should someone verify?

They should check that the example satisfies every assumption and clearly fails the conclusion.

  1. Broken mathematical loop beside the words AI Breaks an 87-Year Math Problem
    Claude Just Did the Impossible
    AI Copium7m 36s1 VIEW
  2. Pierce Freeman, Richard Diehl Martinez, Levent Alp枚ge against black with the blue and white headline "ONE COUNTEREXAMPLE CHANGES EVERYTHING".
  3. Pierce Freeman, Richard Diehl Martinez, Levent Alp枚ge, Terence Tao against black with the blue and white headline "AI BREAKTHROUGH, OPEN QUESTIONS".
Definition card for counterexample: What is counterexample?

A counterexample is a specific case that shows a general claim is false.